The bridge is cracked badly right through the pin holes. When I look inside, I see the smears of glue from the regluing of the braces right under the bridge, where all the stress is concentrated. In this picture you can see the pickguard curling up as well.
Looking at the bridge plate I see that the wood was mostly chipped out between the holes. Here's a view with the INSIGHT inspection camera. Notice how the wood is missing for at least half its thickness right at the holes.
I do not understand why virtually all makers run the grain direction of bridge plates parallel to the length of the bridge. With the grain running this way the bridge plate can't do its job so well. The function of the bridge plate is to reinforce the top for seating the string balls, and TO KEEP THE TOP FLAT SO THE BRIDGE STAYS IN PLACE. Without a bridge plate, the spruce top would have a much greater tendency to "peel" loose from under the bridge.
When the holes are drilled through the plate, most factory guitars suffer a little chipping out. Then later, as strings are changed, more chipping. This poor guitar's top began to fold right on the dotted line!
On to the business:
I'm heating the bridge to soften the glue underneath. My heater is one of those rubber heat elements like the ones sold by L.M.I. I specially ordered this one 1" x 6" for regular steel string guitar bridges. The L.M.I. ones are 5" long and do the job well also. I wrap the element in aluminum foil for a little better contact, and weight the ends with lead and the cord with a sandbag to keep it from shifting. The heater reaches about 400 degrees, so I have to keep close watch!
I reach inside to feel when I think the temperature is about right, take the heater off, and start to lift the bridge with my flexible knife. The glue is very soft and the bridge comes off cleanly.
Holy Moly! Look what I found:
The top is a real mess under that bridge. It's not the worst, but it's bad enough. Whoever took the bridge off last time ripped big holes in the spruce. Those inlaid patches of spruce were an attempt to do the right thing, but they obviously cut right through the spruce in the very area where the holes, grain direction and chipped wood of the bridge plate make it the top weak as well. The inlaid patches are well done, and tightly glued. The bridge was tightly glued, too, but it cracked because everything underneath folded on the line of the bridge pin holes.
The job is clear now. It's time to overlay the bridge plate to improve rigidity.
Removing the old bridge plate would be a big risk, what with all the damage right where the bridge glues on. There's no big problem in gluing on a new bridge, but I don't want it to crack. Cost is also a factor. Replacing the big original rosewood bridge plate is just too expensive for the owner, and for the value range of the guitar. Bridge plate overlays can always be removed, by the way, should there be a future reason to change the style of the repair.
More